Tony Todd’s 9 Most Underrated Movies

Tony Todd passed away on November 6, 2024, and was unforgivably overlooked at this year’s Oscars’ In Memoriam. A legend within the horror community, he was perhaps best known for his chilling performance as the titular character in the 1992 psychological horror film Candyman, but his career goes far beyond that.

Tony Todd starred in dozens of other films, including all the Final Destination movies except for the fourth installment, and will posthumously reprise his role in the upcoming sixth installment, Final Destination: Bloodlines. Todd was also in The Crow alongside Brandon Lee, the Night of the Living Dead remake, as well as The Rock, the Academy Award-winning film Platoon, and the biopic Lean on Me.

Never one to be afraid to take risks and a staple within the horror genre, here we’re looking at 10 great movies starring Tony Todd that are criminally underrated and never got the respect or recognition they deserved.

9

‘Caught Up’ (1998)

Caught Up

Release Date

February 27, 1998

Runtime

97 minutes

Director

Darin Scott

• Cynda Williams

  Trish / Vanessa

A story about an ex-con who finds himself drawn back into his old ways might not sound like the most original concept for an urban crime drama, but there are enough twists and turns to keep viewers engaged throughout, along with a healthy injection of humor to balance the drama.

Cynda Williams Is the Real Show Stealer

Tony Todd does a fine job as the parole officer, bringing his signature gravitas to the role and exuding an air of authority and quiet menace. Elsewhere, Bokeem Woodbine, LL Cool J, Snoop Dogg, and Michael Clarke Duncan all deliver noteworthy performances, but the real show stealer is Cynda Williams and her portrayal of the ex-con’s new girlfriend. Her alluring presence commands attention whenever she’s onscreen, with a blend of charm and quiet intensity. If you’re able to look past the low budget, Caught Up is a stylish, unpredictable crime thriller that deserves more attention than it got.

Related

The 20 Most Rewatchable 1990s Horror Movies

With time winding down on the 31 Days of October, don’t miss out on rewatching these 1990s horror classics!

8

‘Frankenstein’ (2015)

Frankenstein

Release Date

August 29, 2015

Runtime

89 minutes

Director

Bernard Rose

Mary Shelley’s story of Frankenstein has been retold countless times through the medium of cinema, from the classic Universal Monsters and Hammer Horror adaptations to Tim Burton’s own takes on the story in both Frankenweenie and Edward Scissorhands. Told from the monster’s point of view, 2015’s Frankenstein takes the creation from its original 19th-century gothic setting and brings it into the modern age.

‘Frankenstein’ Focuses on Emotional Storytelling Over Typical Horror Tropes

The original story is one of emotion, heart, and humanity—a cautionary tale of unchecked ambition—and 2015’s movie iteration captures this sentiment by choosing to focus more on emotional storytelling than on typical horror tropes. Adopting this tone makes the violent and horrific moments all the more shocking. Tony Todd brings much of this heart and emotion to the movie, playing a blind, homeless man who takes the monster under his wing after feeling a connection and recognizing his childlike soul.

7

‘Badland’ (2019)

Badland

Release Date

November 1, 2019

Runtime

117 minutes

Director

Justin Lee

Set after the American Civil War, Badland follows a Pinkerton detective who is hired by a newly appointed African American senator, played by Tony Todd, to track down the worst of the Confederate war criminals.

Don’t Expect All-Out Action

Badland, while a revenge story at heart, is a slow-burning, atmospheric, character-driven film that focuses just as much on the internal struggles of its lead protagonist as it does on the apprehension of the criminals. Full of dusky landscapes and desolate towns, director Justin Lee immerses viewers in a gritty Wild West inhabited by outlaws and bounty hunters. The film was mostly overlooked by mainstream audiences at the time of its release, but one can’t help but wonder how different this might have been had it been released during the Western genre’s heyday.

6

‘Army of the Damned’ (2013)

Army of the Damned

Release Date

November 7, 2013

Runtime

85 minutes

Director

Tom DeNucci

Producers

Carl V. Dupré, David Gere, Anthony Gudas, Claire Severance, Chad A. Verdi, Gino Pereira, Michael Corso, David Lussier, Sherry Lussier, Seth Rosenblit

• Michael Berryman

  Crazy Earl

The filming of a reality TV show goes horribly wrong when police are called out to a “domestic disturbance” that proves to be anything but a routine call. All hell breaks loose as the small-town police force finds themselves battling a malevolent force and supernatural creatures while simultaneously providing the TV crew with the best footage they could have dreamed of.

‘Army of the Damned’ Was Made on a Shoestring Budget

Army of the Damned breaks no new ground, nor does it try to. Instead, what we get is a good old-fashioned action-horror romp full of over-the-top practical effects and cheesy one-liners. It’s worth noting that despite being billed as a main star, Todd only appears for several minutes. The leading role duties fall on Godsmack frontman Sully Erna, who rises to the occasion as the hometown hero cop. Elsewhere, horror icon Michael “Crazy Earl” Berryman also makes an appearance. If you love yourself some low-budget action-horror silliness, this may well be a hidden gem waiting for you to discover.

5

‘Death House’ (2018)

death house

Release Date

February 28, 2018

Runtime

88 minutes

Director

Harrison Smith

• Cody Longo

  Agent Jae Novak

• Cortney Palm

  Agent Toria Boon

Death House follows two agents fighting for their lives as they try to escape a secret prison that houses the deadliest killers known to man. Covering all bases by combining the slasher genre with zombies, monsters, and supernatural elements, Death House is a surefire hit for fans of Todd and the horror genre in general and remains criminally underrated.

‘The Expendables’ of Horror

Similar to how Sylvester Stallone assembled a vast array of action icons, past and present, for The Expendables film series, Death House writer Gunnar Hansen initially intended for the film to feature as many horror legends as possible. Notable actors from the world of horror featured in the film, aside from Tony Todd, include Kane Hodder, Barbara Crampton, Bill Moseley, Dee Wallace, Camille Keaton, Sid Haig, Felissa Rose, Adrienne Barbeau, and Michael Berryman.

4

‘Hell Fest’ (2018)

Hell Fest

Release Date

September 27, 2018

Writers

Seth M. Sherwood, Blair Butler

Directed by Gregory Plotkin, Hell Fest is a blood-soaked slasher flick that centers around a group of teenagers relentlessly stalked by a serial killer at a traveling Halloween carnival.

Tony Todd’s Appearance Is Small but Memorable

Tony Todd plays the part of a creepy carnival barker. Adorned in full carnival regalia, the horror icon’s haunting, inimitable voice and presence serve as an omen of the horror to come. The movie is a great throwback to the classic slashers of the ’80s and ’90s, providing plenty of gory deaths and sudden scares that will go down a treat with fans of the genre.

Related

13 A-List Actors that Appeared in ’90s Horror Movies

Horror has always been a great way for actors to get noticed, and the 1990s provided us with some of Hollywood’s greatest A-listers.

3

‘Minotaur’ (2006)

Minotaur

Release Date

March 11, 2006

Runtime

93 Minutes

Director

Jonathan English

Before he rose to superstardom, Tom Hardy appeared in the low-budget horror film Minotaur alongside genre icons Tony Todd, Ingrid Pitt, and Rutger Hauer. The film is a loose retelling of the Greek myth of Theseus and the Minotaur.

What ‘Minotaur’ Lacks in Sheen and Polish, It Makes Up for in Grim Atmosphere and B-Movie Charm

Those looking for groundbreaking special effects and huge action set pieces will find little to quench their thirst here, but if grim, atmospheric horror with an endearing B-movie charm is more your bag, Minotaur has it in spades.

2

‘Hatchet II’ (2010)

Hatchet II

Release Date

October 1, 2010

Runtime

85 Minutes

Released in 2006, the original Hatchet was a fantastic, blood-soaked throwback to the classic slashers of yesteryear. Despite mixed reviews and initial struggles at the box office, it later went on to develop a strong cult following among horror fans. As a result, there have since been three sequels, with another two reportedly in the works.

Tony Todd Is Given a Bigger Role

Tony Todd reprises his role in Hatchet II as Reverend Zombie, a shady conman and voodoo shop owner who profits off the legend of the killer Victor Crowley. This time, given a far larger and more crucial role, he is also, *spoiler alert*, killed off in one of the most brutal ways in the franchise. Despite receiving the lowest Rotten Tomatoes score of the series, many horror buffs prefer it to the original due to its more creative and violent kills and the way it expands the Victor Crowley mythos.

1

‘Sushi Girl’ (2012)

Sushi Girl

Release Date

December 7, 2012

Runtime

98 minutes

Director

Kern Saxton

Sushi Girl takes place over the course of a sushi meal served atop a silent, naked woman, hosted by a ruthless crime lord. As he and four other members of his gang dine together, the evening soon descends into bloody chaos as they turn on one member and try to extract the whereabouts of a hidden stash of stolen diamonds from him.

‘Sushi Girl’ Evokes Tarantino in the Best Kind of Way

Unfolding through a series of nonlinear flashbacks, Sushi Girl plays out in classic Quentin Tarantino fashion, with director Kern Saxton clearly wearing his influences on his sleeve. Filled with intriguing characters, sharp dialogue, and dark humor, Sushi Girl is a modern grindhouse classic, doused in bouts of extreme violence and featuring strong performances from its talented cast of genre favorites, including Tony Todd and Mark Hamill.

You can view the original article HERE.