A Haunting in Venice movie review (2023)


It would be unsporting to say much about the rest of the plot. Reading the book won’t give anything important away because—even more so than in Branagh’s previous Poirot films—the kinship between source and adaptation is a bit like the later James Bond films, which might take a title, some character names and locations, and one or two ideas, and invent everything else. Green, who also wrote the recent “Death on the Nile” as well as “Blade Runner 2049” and much of the series “American Gods,” is a reliably excellent screenwriter of fresh stories inspired by canonical material. His work keeps one eye on commerce and the other on art, reminding nostalgia-motivated viewers in the “intellectual property” era of why they like something. At the same time, Green introduces provocative new elements and attempts a different tone or focus than audiences probably expected. (The introduction to the movie tie-in paperback of Christie’s novel has an introduction by Green that starts with the screenwriter confessing to a murder of “the book you are holding.”)

What’s most fascinating, from that standpoint, is how this Poirot mystery aligns itself with the popular culture being made in Allied countries after World War II. Classic post-war English-language films like “The Best Years of Our Lives,” “The Third Man,” “The Fallen Idol,” and mid-career Welles films like “Touch of Evil” and “The Trial” (to name just a few classics that Branagh seems keenly aware of) were not just engrossing, beautifully crafted entertainments, but illustrations of a pervasive collective feeling of moral exhaustion and soiled idealism—the result of living through a six-year period that showcased previously unimaginable horrors, including Stalingrad, Normandy, the mechanized extermination of the Holocaust, and the use of atomic bombs against civilians. And so the embittered Poirot is a seeming atheist who practically sneers at speaking to the dead. Green and Branagh even give him a monologue about his disillusionment that evokes comments made about Christie near the end of her life, and in the novel, about what she perceived as increasingly cruel tendencies in humanity as a whole, reflected in the sorts of crimes that were being committed.  

Aside from a few period-specific details and references, the source seems to exist outside of the time in which it was written. Branagh and Green’s movie goes in the opposite direction. It’s very much of a particular era: the late 1940s. The children in the film are orphans of war and post-war occupation (soldiers fathered some of them, then went back home without taking responsibility for their actions). There’s talk of “battle fatigue,” which is what PTSD was called during World War II; in the previous world war, they called it “shell shock.” The plot hinges on the economic desperation of native citizens, previously moneyed expatriates who are too emotionally and often financially shattered to recapture the way of life they had before the war, and the mostly Eastern European refugees who didn’t have much to start with and do the country’s grunt work. The overriding sense is that at least some of these characters would literally kill to get back to being whatever they were before.

You can view the original article HERE.

Short Films in Focus: Trapped (with Sam Cutler-Kreutz)
Short Films in Focus: Trapped (with Sam Cutler-Kreutz)
Hulu’s “The Testaments” Returns to Gilead For Another Timely Tale About Privilege and Complicity 
Hulu’s “The Testaments” Returns to Gilead For Another Timely Tale About Privilege and Complicity 
Sundance 2026: Extra Geography, Filipiñana, The Huntress | Festivals & Awards
Sundance 2026: Extra Geography, Filipiñana, The Huntress | Festivals & Awards
Jonathan Glazer’s “Birth” is Resurrected in a Haunting Criterion 4K Release | DVD/Blu-Ray
Jonathan Glazer’s “Birth” is Resurrected in a Haunting Criterion 4K Release | DVD/Blu-Ray
Tony Iommi, Carl Cox and Cerys Matthews named on King’s Birthday Honours list
Tony Iommi, Carl Cox and Cerys Matthews named on King’s Birthday Honours list
Harry Styles pays tribute to David Hockney and reflects on One Direction days as he kicks off record-breaking Wembley run
Harry Styles pays tribute to David Hockney and reflects on One Direction days as he kicks off record-breaking Wembley run
“It was my favourite Foo Fighters show of our fucking lives”
“It was my favourite Foo Fighters show of our fucking lives”
Lily Allen leads the Suffragettes in ‘Virginia Woolf’s Night And Day’ clip
Lily Allen leads the Suffragettes in ‘Virginia Woolf’s Night And Day’ clip
Grace, Growth & Evolution: Cape Fear, Brilliant & Criminal Minds Impress
Grace, Growth & Evolution: Cape Fear, Brilliant & Criminal Minds Impress
It’s Time for Chicago Fire to Push Severide Into OFI Once and For All
It’s Time for Chicago Fire to Push Severide Into OFI Once and For All
Sweet Magnolias Season 5 Gave Erik and Helen Their Hard-Earned Happy Ending
Sweet Magnolias Season 5 Gave Erik and Helen Their Hard-Earned Happy Ending
Power Book III: Raising Kanan Season 5 Episode 1 Gives Us Kanan Making His Worst Decision Yet
Power Book III: Raising Kanan Season 5 Episode 1 Gives Us Kanan Making His Worst Decision Yet
Online Slot Gaming Through the Lens of Micro-Moments
Online Slot Gaming Through the Lens of Micro-Moments
How USMNT can beat Paraguay in World Cup opener
How USMNT can beat Paraguay in World Cup opener
Ohtani exits with knee inflammation, Roberts hopeful star can play Friday
Ohtani exits with knee inflammation, Roberts hopeful star can play Friday
White Sox beat Braves, move into 1st place in AL Central
White Sox beat Braves, move into 1st place in AL Central
Harry Styles Names Two New Songs and Tells Listeners Almost Nothing Else
Harry Styles Names Two New Songs and Tells Listeners Almost Nothing Else
Gordon Ramsay Brings a Korean Twist to the Classic Juicy Lucy Burger
Gordon Ramsay Brings a Korean Twist to the Classic Juicy Lucy Burger
Giannis Antetokounmpo Lands A Breitling Deal As His Brand Reaches New Heights
Giannis Antetokounmpo Lands A Breitling Deal As His Brand Reaches New Heights
Jamie Lee Curtis Recruited Ariana DeBose for ‘Scarpetta’ With a Single Text
Jamie Lee Curtis Recruited Ariana DeBose for ‘Scarpetta’ With a Single Text
A Huge New Hire at Chanel, Carven’s New Creative Director
A Huge New Hire at Chanel, Carven’s New Creative Director
The Hamptons It List: Where To Go This Summer
The Hamptons It List: Where To Go This Summer
10 Father’s Day Gifts at Tecovas, From Bestselling Boots to Elevated Basics
10 Father’s Day Gifts at Tecovas, From Bestselling Boots to Elevated Basics
7 Trader Joe’s Summer Skincare Dupes We Cannot Get Enough of
7 Trader Joe’s Summer Skincare Dupes We Cannot Get Enough of
Paulino Releases “Don’t Give Up On Me” — A Global Anthem of Resilience Lands Worldwide
Paulino Releases “Don’t Give Up On Me” — A Global Anthem of Resilience Lands Worldwide
The Ultimate Chip By Howard Bloom
The Ultimate Chip By Howard Bloom
Epic, High-Voltage Announcement
Epic, High-Voltage Announcement
Lost Weekend: Turncoat Syndicate’s Energetic Return to Alt. Rock
Lost Weekend: Turncoat Syndicate’s Energetic Return to Alt. Rock