The Hunting Party Season 1 Episode 9 Review: Who Goes Undercover To Trick a Sadistic Killer?

The Hunting Party Season 1 Episode 9 Review: Who Goes Undercover To Trick a Sadistic Killer?

Critic’s Rating: 4.4 / 5.0

4.4

It’s terrifying to get inside a serial killer’s mind.

While Bex Henderson has profiled several on The Hunting Party, the series took it to the next level with “Tom Beecher”.

The sadistic serial killer on The Hunting Party Season 1 Episode 9 relished in emotionally torturing female victims before murdering them in front of a second victim.

(David Astorga/NBC)

This case affected almost every team member as more secrets were revealed about Tom’s treatment in the Pit and the newest victims.

Serial killers who torture their victims violently are awful, but those who torture their victims psychologically, too, deserve a special place in hell.

I’m unsure which was more disturbing: watching someone die like that or those messages he would leave.

Tom Beecher relished making his victims feel helpless, but he made it worse by choosing young women who were close to their families.

(James Dittiger/NBC)

All these women wanted was to see their parents and reassure them of their love. That had to be the worst nightmare of Lily’s parents’ life.

I understood why Bex wanted them to accept Tom’s call, but hearing how he wanted to play games with her was creepy.

I don’t know how any of the team didn’t lose it. Bex and Hassani have daughters, and Oliver has a short fuse.

It was evident that Tom had a past with Bex, and I wish they had dug into that more. Was she the one that arrested him? Had Oliver been involved in that case?

Tom seemed obsessed with making women feel helpless, and that included Bex.

Tom Beecher Triggered Jennifer Morales Enough To Go Undercover and Get Justice For These Women

(David Astorga/NBC)

The Hunting Party has been one of those series whose short seasons have hurt it. We barely knew anything about Jennifer Morales and why chasing serial killers, especially this one, mattered to her.

She identified with Lily, the young woman trying to leave Casper, Wyoming, for college. She wanted her to succeed, so she motivated herself to find her.

It’s heartbreaking enough that Tom Beecher relished torturing his victims, but Dr. Dulles’s experimental brain surgery worsened it.

Tom couldn’t remember where he had stashed Lily, and he enjoyed how helpless Bex felt, so he didn’t want to help them.

I loved how Bex and Morales showed how fierce they were. Morales didn’t hesitate when she volunteered to be the second female Tom tortured so the team could reach Lily.

(David Astorga/NBC)

You could tell that Morales had become a younger sister to the team by how protective they were. That knife Hassani attached to her sneaker saved her life since.

Tom Beecher only cared about himself. He would rather kill himself and make Bex and Morales suffer, knowing Lily died on their watch.

Only Morales refused to let that happen. With Shane’s help, she cracked his code. Sometimes, being a nerd is the best thing when those skills pay off and reunite a family.

While I wish we could have seen more of Morales in the field, “Tom Beecher” was the ideal episode to drop her into.

Bonus: March was National Women’s Month, and we saw her in action on the last day of March.

Dr. Dulles Appeared More Evil, and That Plan Could Have Affected Shane

(James Dittiger/NBC)

Shane became more traumatized the more he learned about Dr. Dulles. Even Sarah felt sorry for him and probably re-thought everything she knew about her father.

It’s difficult to sympathize with Dr. Dulles even though we thought we would as we watched his memory deteriorate with Alzheimer’s disease.

However, it’s challenging to discern if he practiced brain surgery on Tom Beecher to see learn new coping mechanisms with memory, or if he was an evil scientist who enjoyed torturing these Pit prisoners.

Shane didn’t want to believe anything negative about Dr. Dulles. He had known him his entire life, and he kept struggling with learning his identity and that pesky nature-versus-nurture battle.

This only intensified it since he didn’t know who to trust.

This case also triggered Shane. He saw how these parents reacted, and while his parents were good people, he didn’t seem close to them. He longed for that.

(James Dittiger/NBC)

Why was he keeping Shane’s birth mother from him? If it were because of closed adoption laws, I’d understand it, but I suspect he had a more sinister reason.

Dr. Dulles almost seemed to be like Dr. Jeckel and Mr. Hyde. He could appear sweet and caring but was a diabolical evil doctor.

He seemed to enjoy torturing some of those prisoners, and maybe he wanted to torture Shane’s mom by keeping her from her son.

It’s also possible that Shane’s parents were serial killers, and he prevented exposure to that, so Shane would evolve into the upstanding man he is today.

Is The Team Ready To Learn the Truth About the Blast?

Someone wants the truth to disappear. It’s disturbing that the head of Research at Whitmore Industries mysteriously died.

Oliver’s contact hinted that he should back off, but by now, his loyalty was with Bex and Hassani, so he demanded answers.

(David Astorga/NBC)

His contact appeared to be one of the people in charge since she resisted when threatened.

I wonder if Oliver has something on her since he ultimately got her to reveal something important about the Pit and meet him and Bex.

We won’t know until The Hunting Party’s Season 1 finale if she reveals anything helpful or if these secrets will remain hidden until a potential second season.

That secret likely deals with the Pit’s purpose and what really went on behind closed doors.

Over to you, The Hunting Party Fanatics. What did you think of “Tom Beecher”?

What do you think Dr. Dulles knows about Shane?

We would love to hear your thoughts, so drop your theories in the comments.

.

Anonymous Vote

Sign in with WordPress

Watch The Hunting Party Online

TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.

You can view the original article HERE.

Erica Muse Doubles Down on Horror Genre Films with Two New Releases
Erica Muse Doubles Down on Horror Genre Films with Two New Releases
Short Films in Focus: Trapped (with Sam Cutler-Kreutz)
Short Films in Focus: Trapped (with Sam Cutler-Kreutz)
Hulu’s “The Testaments” Returns to Gilead For Another Timely Tale About Privilege and Complicity 
Hulu’s “The Testaments” Returns to Gilead For Another Timely Tale About Privilege and Complicity 
Sundance 2026: Extra Geography, Filipiñana, The Huntress | Festivals & Awards
Sundance 2026: Extra Geography, Filipiñana, The Huntress | Festivals & Awards
“The thought of dying without ever making my mark, that was my biggest fear”
“The thought of dying without ever making my mark, that was my biggest fear”
Kacey Musgraves brutally hits back at Kristi Noem’s criticism
Kacey Musgraves brutally hits back at Kristi Noem’s criticism
Watch Sunflower Bean’s Julia Cumming step in on bass for Wolf Alice as they support Olivia Rodrigo on US tour
Watch Sunflower Bean’s Julia Cumming step in on bass for Wolf Alice as they support Olivia Rodrigo on US tour
“I’m speechless that something like that can exist on live national television”
“I’m speechless that something like that can exist on live national television”
All American Season 8 Episode 10 Review: Nothing is More Important Than Family
All American Season 8 Episode 10 Review: Nothing is More Important Than Family
It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia Season 18 Episode 5 Review: The Glory and Guts of Ren Faire Culture
It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia Season 18 Episode 5 Review: The Glory and Guts of Ren Faire Culture
Dead City Season 3 Episode 7 Review: Maggie Takes a Stand for Negan!
Dead City Season 3 Episode 7 Review: Maggie Takes a Stand for Negan!
Fightland Season 1 Episode 6 Review: There Is a War Coming, and Kingsley Is Out for Blood
Fightland Season 1 Episode 6 Review: There Is a War Coming, and Kingsley Is Out for Blood
‘I was wrong’ – Candace Parker apologise to Angel Reese over past comments before WNBA Finals
‘I was wrong’ – Candace Parker apologise to Angel Reese over past comments before WNBA Finals
Bengals TE Tanner Hudson to miss rest of season with torn pectoral
Bengals TE Tanner Hudson to miss rest of season with torn pectoral
Haway The Podcast | European Memories from 1973
Haway The Podcast | European Memories from 1973
3 Fantasy Football Week 6 Waiver Wire Adds No One Is Talking About
3 Fantasy Football Week 6 Waiver Wire Adds No One Is Talking About
Brooklyn Shop Says Kelly Clarkson’s Negative Review Has Put Them In Danger: ‘We Find Her Gross Abuse Of Power Completely Reprehensible’
Brooklyn Shop Says Kelly Clarkson’s Negative Review Has Put Them In Danger: ‘We Find Her Gross Abuse Of Power Completely Reprehensible’
Denise Richards’ Alarming New Claims: Aaron Phypers Secretly Monitored Her, Accessed Her Devices, & More During Abusive Marriage
Denise Richards’ Alarming New Claims: Aaron Phypers Secretly Monitored Her, Accessed Her Devices, & More During Abusive Marriage
RJ Mitte Fans Urge Social Media Users To Be Kinder & Think Twice Before Leaving ‘Rude’ Comments
RJ Mitte Fans Urge Social Media Users To Be Kinder & Think Twice Before Leaving ‘Rude’ Comments
Breaking Bad Star & Disability Rights Advocate RJ Mitte Dies At 34
Breaking Bad Star & Disability Rights Advocate RJ Mitte Dies At 34
Kendall Jenner Gets A Promotion
Kendall Jenner Gets A Promotion
Meet Designer Jamie Haller
Meet Designer Jamie Haller
Todd Snyder and Lagavulin Launch Collection
Todd Snyder and Lagavulin Launch Collection
Vanessa Gordon On How To Create The Perfect Event
Vanessa Gordon On How To Create The Perfect Event
Ray Ray Star Heads to Nashville for the Josie Music Awards
Ray Ray Star Heads to Nashville for the Josie Music Awards
REDEMPTION: A QUEEN OF WARRI’S JOURNEY BACK TO HERSELF
REDEMPTION: A QUEEN OF WARRI’S JOURNEY BACK TO HERSELF
Erica Muse Doubles Down on Horror Genre Films with Two New Releases
Erica Muse Doubles Down on Horror Genre Films with Two New Releases
Paulino Releases “Don’t Give Up On Me” — A Global Anthem of Resilience Lands Worldwide
Paulino Releases “Don’t Give Up On Me” — A Global Anthem of Resilience Lands Worldwide