The Next Generation Writer Fought TNG Producer’s Idiotic Rule in Order to Mention Mr. Spock’s Name

The Next Generation Writer Fought TNG Producer’s Idiotic Rule in Order to Mention Mr. Spock’s Name

The Next Generation Writer Fought TNG Producer’s Idiotic Rule in Order to Mention Mr. Spock’s Name

Summary

  • TNG writer Ira Steven Behr fought tooth and nail to mention Mr. Spock’s name in the season three episode, Sarek.
  • Executive producer Rick Berman honored a strict rule against including characters or aliens from the original series in TNG, which was concocted by Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry.
  • Despite this cumbersome rule, TOS characters like Mr. Spock, Dr. McCoy, Mr. Scott and Ambassador Sarek did make appearances on TNG, much to the delight of Trekkies.

Leaving Mr. Spock out of Star Trek: The Next Generation (TNG) would quite simply have been illogical. But in The Fifty-Year Mission: The Complete, Uncensored, Unauthorized Oral History of Star Trek: The First 25 Years, which was penned by authors Edward Gross and Mark A. Altman, TNG writer Ira Steven Behr addressed the struggles he faced just mentioning the famous Vulcan’s name in the season three episode, titled Sarek, (per Screen Rant):

“When we did the ‘Sarek’ rewrite, the fight over the word ‘Spock’ was insane. I was absolutely not allowed to use the word ‘Spock.’ Rick [Berman] made a big issue of it and said we can’t do it. There’s no way. We did it once. We had McCoy show up at the beginning, but no more. No references to the original series. I said, ‘It’s Spock’s father, we’re already in that territory.’ He said, ‘Absolutely not.’”

The Emmy-nominated producer and writer wrote almost 20 episodes of TNG from 1989 until 1990, but Behr found himself at odds with executive producer Rick Berman whenever it came to the inclusion of anything remotely having to do with Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS) in The Next Generation.

Related: The Best Original Star Trek Characters, Ranked

The Quandary of Including TOS in TNG

Paramount Pictures

Executive producer Rick Berman wanted to honor Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry’s wishes for TNG. Roddenberry didn’t want any characters or aliens from TOS to appear in The Next Generation. It’s a rule that was broken right out of the starting gates, though, because an aging Dr. McCoy (DeForest Kelley) actually comes aboard the U.S.S. Enterprise D. And he fully interacts with Data (Brent Spiner) in the TV show’s very first episode, Encounter at Farpoint (1987). But when Mr. Spock’s (Leonard Nimoy) father, Ambassador Sarek (Mark Lenard), came aboard the Enterprise-D in TNG season three, writer Ira Steven Behr almost had to go to war with Berman over the script’s content just to mention Spock’s name! In another excerpt from the book, Behr says:

“About a week later, I was up in his office discussing something else, because there came a point where he only wanted to give me notes or have me there when he was giving other writers notes, so I had to be the one there all the time as he went through the script and went over his little red changes. We were talking about something, and it was kind of benign, and I just suddenly said to him, ‘Rick, tell me again, why can’t we say the word ‘Spock’?’

And his whole body language changed, he leaned back in his chair and flung his hands up behind the back of his head, and I could tell he did not want to have this discussion again. But he couldn’t think of a reason at that very moment, and he just said, ‘OK, you can say it once.’ It was ridiculous.”

Berman’s decision-making process has always been in question where Trekkies are concerned, particularly when he and writers Brannon Braga and Ronald D. Moore controversially killed off Captain Kirk (William Shatner) in the TNG crew’s first big-screen adventure, Star Trek: Generations (1994).

Despite the idiocy of Berman’s rule not to include OG characters from TOS in TNG, many fan favs did show up on the television series during its seven seasons. Sarek, Dr. McCoy, Mr. Spock and Mr. Scott (James Doohan) all showed up and reprised their roles from The Original Series on The Next Generation. And check out Dr. McCoy’s short but memorable visit aboard the U.S.S. Enterprise-D below:

You can view the original article HERE.

Josephine review – breathtaking and masterful
Josephine review – breathtaking and masterful
Episode 3: Wild Horse Nine and Possible Love
Episode 3: Wild Horse Nine and Possible Love
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping review – a thrilling return…
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping review – a thrilling return…
Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother review – a rare, gorgeous action…
Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother review – a rare, gorgeous action…
From LISA of BLACKPINK & Gracie Abrams to the GTA VI Album, Which Music Release Is Your Favorite This Week? Vote!
From LISA of BLACKPINK & Gracie Abrams to the GTA VI Album, Which Music Release Is Your Favorite This Week? Vote!
Muses Matt Bellamy wants an AI guitar – but still calls for human-made art and live performance
Muses Matt Bellamy wants an AI guitar – but still calls for human-made art and live performance
Billie Eilish & FINNEAS Follow Lucy Dickins to CAA for Global Touring, WME to Share in North America
Billie Eilish & FINNEAS Follow Lucy Dickins to CAA for Global Touring, WME to Share in North America
Grand Theft Auto 6 launches after 13-year wait – heres what players are saying
Grand Theft Auto 6 launches after 13-year wait – heres what players are saying
The Good Daughter Author Is Thinking About Writing Sequel
The Good Daughter Author Is Thinking About Writing Sequel
The Gilded Age Showrunner, Cast, Unpack Peggys Wedding & Seed Of Idea For Core Conflict In Season 4
The Gilded Age Showrunner, Cast, Unpack Peggys Wedding & Seed Of Idea For Core Conflict In Season 4
Russell Brand Accuser Mia Latter Waives Anonymity, Alleges Rape
Russell Brand Accuser Mia Latter Waives Anonymity, Alleges Rape
British Actor Says He Was Sexually Humiliated By David Walliams On Stage As UK Entertainment Industry Reflects On Week Of Reckoning
British Actor Says He Was Sexually Humiliated By David Walliams On Stage As UK Entertainment Industry Reflects On Week Of Reckoning
MotoGP Today | Marquez and Martin address championship battle in Malaysia
MotoGP Today | Marquez and Martin address championship battle in Malaysia
Sunderland Are Eyeing A January Move For This Ligue 1 Winger: Good Fit For Le Bris?
Sunderland Are Eyeing A January Move For This Ligue 1 Winger: Good Fit For Le Bris?
Texas Tech paid Skydance Sports $999K to make Paramount+ docuseries about football program
Texas Tech paid Skydance Sports $999K to make Paramount+ docuseries about football program
Mizzou cross country aims high as SEC Championships hit Columbia
Mizzou cross country aims high as SEC Championships hit Columbia
The Challenges Cory Wharton Shares Mental Health Update: 'OK to Not Be OK'
The Challenges Cory Wharton Shares Mental Health Update: 'OK to Not Be OK'
Jennifer Lawrence Reveals Her New Full C Breast Implants on WWHL
Jennifer Lawrence Reveals Her New Full C Breast Implants on WWHL
Kim Zolciak Facing 6-Figure Default Judgment Over Defunct Business
Kim Zolciak Facing 6-Figure Default Judgment Over Defunct Business
'Baywatch' Alum Erika Eleniak, 57, Says OnlyFans Saved Her from Being Evicted
'Baywatch' Alum Erika Eleniak, 57, Says OnlyFans Saved Her from Being Evicted
Willy Chavarria Lands Museum Exhibition, Launches New Bag Collection
Willy Chavarria Lands Museum Exhibition, Launches New Bag Collection
Erewhons Iconic Smoothies Land a Permanent Home in SoHo
Erewhons Iconic Smoothies Land a Permanent Home in SoHo
Moses Martin Performs for Sister Apple at Burberrys Holiday Party
Moses Martin Performs for Sister Apple at Burberrys Holiday Party
I Walked 20,000 Steps at Camp Flog Gnaw — These Shoes Got Me Through It
I Walked 20,000 Steps at Camp Flog Gnaw — These Shoes Got Me Through It
Luma Valen on Her “Frequency,” International Growth, and Building an Entertainment Empire with Purpose
Luma Valen on Her “Frequency,” International Growth, and Building an Entertainment Empire with Purpose
Ray Ray Star Heads to Nashville for the Josie Music Awards
Ray Ray Star Heads to Nashville for the Josie Music Awards
REDEMPTION: A QUEEN OF WARRI’S JOURNEY BACK TO HERSELF
REDEMPTION: A QUEEN OF WARRI’S JOURNEY BACK TO HERSELF
Erica Muse Doubles Down on Horror Genre Films with Two New Releases
Erica Muse Doubles Down on Horror Genre Films with Two New Releases